Thomas R. Cutler Mansion

1900

Thomas R. Cutler was one of the most prominent men in the early history of Lehi. He was the owner of the highly successful People’s Co-op, which was in the Osmond Design building on State Street at 151 E. State.

In 1891, he became the general manager of the Lehi Factory of the Utah & Idaho Sugar Company. He worked for the company for 28 years although not all of those years were in Lehi. He was Lehi’s wealthiest citizen of the time.

In 1900, he began construction of a $14,000 home on his State Street property—a home that is a near duplicate of the Jesse Knight Mansion in Provo. Both were designed by architects Ware and Treganze. The “Cutler Mansion,” as Lehi people have called the Colonial Revival box-style home, was the “finest resident south of Salt Lake,” according to the Jan. 17, 1901, Lehi Banner.

The home was briefly the Reltuc Inn (Cutler spelled backwards). From 1914-1925, Lehi native Dr. Frederick Daniel Worlton ran the Lehi Hospital in the home. Worlton established 10 patient rooms and an operating room upstairs while he and his family lived downstairs.

Wallace and Arlene Olsen purchased the home in 1967, when it needed many repairs, and restored it to its former glory. In 1984, the stately mansion was listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Although Wally passed away last year, Arlene continues to live in and take care of the beautiful mansion.

Thomas R. Cutler Mansion Historical Marker Unveiling

May 10, 2025

More than 100 people gathered for the historical marker unveiling at the stately pink mansion at 150 East State St.

A family member from each of the home’s major historic eras spoke, and the Lehi Silver Band played as it did at the opening of the Reltuc, Cutler spelled backwards, Inn.

 In 1900, Lehi’s most prominent citizen, Thomas R. Cutler, began construction of his Colonial Revival box-style home on State Street. It was soon dubbed the “Cutler Mansion.”

The Jan. 17, 1902, Lehi Banner declared the Cutler Mansion, “the finest residence south of Salt Lake.”

The late Wallace “Wally” Olsen and his wife, Arlene, purchased the home in 1977. Through the years, they worked to bring the home back to its former glory while maintaining its historical integrity. The home was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1984. Wally and Arlene operated Outpost Antiques in Sandy, and then Lehi.

The marker is the ninth of the Lehi Historical Marker Program.

Collector pins celebrate Lehi’s history and support the Lehi Historical Society

Tithing Barn Pin
$10.00

Celebrate the legacy of Lehi’s early pioneers with this detailed hard enamel pin depicting the historic Tithing Barn, also known as “Centennial Hall.” Built in 1872 and later used as a central site for donated goods, the barn played a key role in supporting local families and the broader church community.

The colorful design features:

  • The 1876 Centennial Hall bunting

  • A cart full of produce

  • Pigs, chickens, and historic details symbolizing the goods once collected as tithes

  • A nod to the July 4, 1876 celebration, when ice cream was first served in Lehi beneath the barn’s willow trees

Product Details:

  • Hard enamel pin, 2.0 mm thick

  • Polished metal finish

  • 1.75 inches wide

  • Double star-posted for extra security

  • Includes a back stamp and Lehi Historical Society seal

  • Features Centennial Hall, livestock, produce cart, and historic setting

This pin commemorates the rich history of faith, generosity, and community in Lehi. A perfect addition to your collection or a meaningful gift for anyone who loves Utah history.

Lehi Roller Mills Pin
$12.00

Celebrate one of Utah’s most iconic landmarks with this beautifully crafted Historical Marker collector pin. Featuring the historic Lehi Roller Mills in striking detail, this enamel pin captures the distinctive architecture and nostalgic charm of the century-old mill, known for its role in Footloose and its deep roots in Lehi’s agricultural heritage.

  • Premium soft enamel with gold-toned metal

  • Accurate architectural rendering of the Roller Mills

  • Measures 2 in wide

  • Double-post backing with secure rubber covers for added stability

  • Perfect for collectors, history lovers, and proud Lehi locals

A timeless keepsake honoring the heart of Lehi’s past.

Purchase collector marker pins to show your Lehi spirit and support for the Lehi Historical Marker Program and the Lehi Historical Society. There are currently 15 pins available.

151 E. State St. Lehi, Utah 84043

MARKER LOCATION

 

Access the online library here.